Trade Knowledge Home -> Trade Question-> Trade >> A stealing was found to be B A pursuit to cross the street when hit by a car, who is to blame? Who is responsible for medical expenses?

A stealing was found to be B A pursuit to cross the street when hit by a car, who is to blame? Who is responsible for medical expenses?

  • [Users questions | Browse:327918 | Favorites]
Users questions:Students in the theft of a bike thief is found, when the students after the thief, the thief suddenly cross the street, Knocked seriously injured by a car. The court held that students pay the thief's medical expenses, is this reasonable? What who is to blame? Who is responsible for the medical expenses it? Best to provide a legal basis, thank you ... ...
Experts answer:Court's decision is lawful and reasonable. 1, the implementation of the thief stealing is illegal, but the spot was found and attempted theft, because no harm can be exempted from punishment. 2, then the owner of the chase behavior is the main reason for injuries caused by thieves hit, namely: the thief acts of serious injury and owners have a direct causal relationship between, so a vehicle to pay a certain bear corresponding civil liability for medical expenses. 3, the owner chased the aim is to protect the legitimate rights and interests of their own, trying to catch the thief's behavior is lawful and reasonable, subjective intent does not want to hit by the thief, the owner can not be the objective situation is expected, therefore, the owner is actually not at fault. On the other hand, the thief ran away to avoid being arrested, apparently for the injury the result is unpredictable. For stealing a bike and brutally injured, obviously the penalty would be too serious. For the results of both the occurrence of serious injuries are not at fault, then only the actual situation, the two parties may share civil liability. Thus, according to
Related to
  • Need a sourcing agent/helper in china
    I am looking for a sourcing agent in china with experience in mobile phone & accessories. Laptops & tablets accessories. Computer accessories and electronics in general. I need someone with complete knowledge of whole process from purchasing to delivery. Contact me ASAP.Please send an email to ,so that we can check the details with you.
  • The person deciding on my dispute did not allow me to provide evidence
    Hello, I have made an order #1112319955 and one of the items did not work. The seller did not help me and I have submitted a complaint #1101222215 with error screenshot as attachments but the person who has been reviewing the complaint asked to provide a video instead, setting the time limit to ridiculous 3 (THREE!) days. I was on a vacation then and was not able to achieve that. I have as...
  • I am not a business, Do not have EIN #, will I have a problem ordering a large shipment at LA Port?
  • The dispute with the seller
    The seller sent my order is not the company that is specified in the order, in a consequence of that delivery of the order was much longer and I get my goods soon, I opened the dispute and escalated it, but so far no measures were taken. As far as I understood the seller is obliged to pay back my full amount of money for the goods, if I don't get it in time. The time came more than a week a...
  • how much do I have to wait for dispute?
    I have disputed my order and waiting already 2 weeks to receive any answer about it. How long do I have to wait more?Life is short, you should as far as possible to make yourself happy. can you give me some advices? contact me through skype: ucnobi_otari
  • What about my dispute
    I escalated my dispute in 2013-04-06. I have no answer a month later. When will resolve this and I get a refund? Case Number: 411567829 (Order Number: 1112052629)
  • palestinian cleaning products importers
    I would like to find a distributor for my cleaning products production what kind of machine?
  • i didnt recive refund for my tansaction
    i need to get refund for order :1113509439 i didnt get it yet what should i do?
  • Case Number: 411469465
    When I receive refund, I have not got this goods, passed plenty of time?
  • Albroobbann prices
    Hi my friend, what do you mean by the word of " Albroobbann "?
  • This information provided by the users.Thanks!